Hello, everyone. Another post on what you won’t learn in screenwriting courses, screenwriting classes or even most screenwriting workshops. The subject: What do we think about readers? This is a question that I hear from lots of the writers I work with. Is it worth it to send your script out for coverage to hopefully get an objective professional eye – someone who can find things you’ve missed or even better to find better solutions to the problems you’ve having?
My take on readers is very cynical. The reason for this is that most readers are frustrated screenwriters themselves, they’ve never had a film made and even worse, they’re right out of film school.
Film school taught them how to be scholarly and critical but didn’t teach them a darn thing about getting their films made or anything really about the film business.
The typical reader who does coverage for a film studio or production company or film contest is not being rewarded to find those films that have a good chance of getting made. They’re being paid to be as nitpicky as possible and to show how clever they are in the jibes they take at the writers they’re judging.
That’s not what you want when you’re looking for an objective take on your screenplay. You want someone who actually knows what it takes to get a screenplay into good enough shape to be bought or optioned for production. You want someone whose gotten films made or at least has been through the process as a producer or production assistant.
I had a reader once as one of my students and over two years of doing coverage for big production companies he passed on two or three films that actually got made. I asked him if he was fired or reprimanded for this. Not at all, he told me. One of the scripts was “Elf,” which eventually starred Will Ferrell. He passed on Elf and there was no blowback from his bosses? How could this be?
Because it’s always safe for a reader to pass, it’s when he recommends something that he’s in some danger. Then his bosses want to read the script and if they don’t think it’s good they blame him. How could he possibly like this crap? So most readers pass on everything.
The right person to do coverage for you is not only smart enough to find clever solutions to the problems you’re having but is excited about finding projects that actually are commercial and have a chance of getting made.
Almost anyone can sense when something is wrong in a screenplay. But it’s the creative individual that can come up with the right ideas in fixing those problems. They need to be creative themselves, not nitpicky critics.
I’m amazed that even development people, your directors of development and creative heads at most companies don’t have a clue about how to fix the problems in a screenplay. They can point out areas that aren’t working but the true talent comes in brainstorming to fix those problems.
And that’s not to say you don’t need professional feedback before you send a script out. The biggest mistake most screenwriters make is that they attempt to market screenplays before they’re ready.
So go to people who have gotten films made themselves, who are creative in their approach, who have professional credits and actually have a stake in finding the next Elf. I’ve found a few of them over the years. If you’re interested, get in touch and I’ll let you know who I’d recommend.
Until then – KEEP WRITING!